Yodha Questions & Answers Forum

Q ;  Compare and Analyse Difference between CBSE vs ICSE vs STATE BOARDS ? 

Ans :

Post by  Navina Anand

Choose the right curriculum for your child
Today, children have more choices in education in picking a curriculum. However it can be a little confusing as to which curriculum is right for your child, as there is no ‘one size fits all’. Picking a curriculum would depend on many factors :what aspirations you and your child have- If going abroad for college education is a goal; If you have a job that requires you to relocate constantly- locally or globally ; If your child has  more varied  interests like art and music, rather than simple basics; And of course the affordability factor. The following are some of the salient points of each curriculum.

1. CBSE (Central Board for Secondary Education)

Pros:Widely available schools under this curriculum

Standardized textbooks (NCERT textbooks)

The curriculum standard is in-line with most college entrance exams

Allows private candidates and those from non-affiliated schools to appear for the exams

Larger focus on maths and science and less on language

Favoured by those who constantly relocate within India and seek a standardized curriculum

Favoured by those who want to go into the traditional routes of Engineering/medical

Cons:

Lesser number of subjects compared to ICSE

More theoretical approach

Focus is mainly on maths and science

You pick a stream, instead of individual subjects in 11th and 12th  such as Science, Commerce, Arts  etc

Click here for an in-depth understanding of CBSE

2. ICSE (Indian Certificate for Secondary Education)

Pros:

Can follow any textbook of their choice

Does not permit candidates from a non-affiliated school to appear for the exam

Equal focus on Language, Art and Science

Offers a larger variety of subjects to choose from

Favoured by those who are interested in more applied knowledge rather than rote learning

Cons:

Greater focus on practical learning than CBSE , but not as much as IB or IGCSE

Curriculum considered to be tougher and more vast than CBSE

More number of subjects compared to CBSE

3. IB (International Baccalaureate)

Pros:

The international Baccalaureate curriculum is popular worldwide

it has 3 sections, the PYP (Primary years program- KG to 5th std), MYP (Middle years program –Std 6-10) and the DYP(Diploma years program, Std 11 and 12)

IB has no prescribed textbooks and a lot of freedom in learning

Focus of curriculum is on Analytical skills, language, arts and humanities

The focus is more on applied knowledge instead of rote learning

The DP core consists of Extended essay , creative/action/service  project and theory of knowledge

At the DYP Level, students can pick a subject each from 6 groups and the DP core

Usually favoured by those who want to send their children abroad for undergraduation or students of parents who will be relocating globally

Cons:

A new entrant in the Indian educational scene

Not aligned to local entrance exam content

More expensive than CBSE and ICSE schools

Difficult to find private tutors for extra coaching

Private students cannot take the exams

A good night’s sleep is absolutely essential for your kid to perform well in any curriculum and here are a few bedtime books that will ensure that.

4. IGCSE (International General Certificate of Secondary Education)

Pros:

International curriculum for Class 9 and 10

It’s the precursor to the IB curriculum in many international schools for 11 and 12

Larger choice of subjects

Assessments include written and oral exams

Application oriented curriculum

There are core subjects which everyone has to pick and then 5 groups of subjects from which one has to be picked ( Maths group, Language group etc )

Ideal for students whose parents tend to relocate globally or students who plan to pursue undergraduation abroad.

Cons:

Difficult to find private tutors who coach in this curriculum

More expensive than CBSE and ICSE schools

5. STATE BOARD

Pros:

Unique to every state in India

Considered easier than all other boards

An inclusive curriculum that tries to accommodate all students of all capabilities

Easy to score high in the public exams

A student who has other interests like sports that take up a lot of time may choose this syllabus to keep the work load easy

Favoured by students who choose this curriculum for scoring high and simultaneously focusing on extra classes to appear for entrance exams like IIT JEE.

Cons:

The syllabus might not be comprehensive enough when compared with other curriculum. This might prove a damper in entrance exams in the 12th standard.

Traditionally has been more of rote learning

State language is usually mandatory, though this varies from state to state

It has been said that the more choices humans have, the more unhappy they are 🙂  The latest in the list of dilemmas that parents have , is the choice of curriculum and school and very few are 100% satisfied with their choice. But all we need to do is take a look at the success stories around us. Whom do we consider most successful? The one who went to the fanciest school and scored the highest marks? Or the one who has the best overall attitude towards life – Something for all of us to ponder